Md. Casler et al., CONVERGENT-DIVERGENT SELECTION FOR SEED PRODUCTION AND FORAGE TRAITS IN ORCHARDGRASS .1. DIRECT SELECTION RESPONSES, Crop science, 37(4), 1997, pp. 1047-1053
Simultaneous improvement of forage traits and seed yield in orchardgra
ss (Dactylis glomerata L.) has been problematic because of geographic
separation of forage and seed production locations. Most attempts to s
imultaneously improve both Forage and seed traits have relied on a sin
gle location. The objective of this study was to conduct and evaluate
two cycles of convergent-divergent (CID) and local selection for panic
le seed weight (PSW) and forage traits. Selection was conducted at fou
r locations (Ames, IA; Mount Vernon, MO; Rock Springs, PA; and Arlingt
on, WI) in four base populations (I79DT, MO2, PLS4, and WO11). Phenoty
pic selection on a spaced-plant basis was applied at a 0.25 selection
intensity for forage traits, followed by a 0.25 selection intensity fo
r PSW. All populations were evaluated as spaced plants at the Iowa and
Pennsylvania locations in 1990 and 1991. Both selection methods were
equally effective at increasing PSW, with responses averaging 1.0 to 1
8.2% cycle(-1). Realized heritabilities for PSW were highly variable a
mong the four populations (mean of 0.03-0.23) and were lower for Cycle
2 than for Cycle 1 (mean of 0.02 vs. 0.16). For C/D selection, IA, MO
, PA, and WI selection locations increased PSW by 25, 39, 94, and 33 m
g panicle(-1) respectively. Three of the four populations had signific
ant genetic changes of 2 to 4 d later heading, despite no direct selec
tion pressure for heading date. There were very few significant and bi
ologically meaningful genotype x location interactions for any trait.
Therefore, neither selection method resulted in plants with differenti
al adaptation when evaluated as spaced plants.