The assessment of depression in patients with brain pathologies-a topi
c of considerable clinical and research interest-is complicated by a v
ariety of factors. Among the most problematic are cognitive consequenc
es of brain injury that can diminish the reliability and validity of i
nformation used to diagnose depression, determine its severity: ascert
ain its predictors, and evaluate its impact. In this article, the auth
ors examine the challenges to depression assessment in patients who ha
ve had a stroke, the neurologically impaired population in which it ha
s been most frequently studied. Focusing on poststroke depression rese
arch, they describe methodological limitations that may contribute to
conflicting outcomes and conclusions and offer suggestions for improvi
ng the specificity, consistency, validity, and reliability of assessme
nt methods and procedures when investigating depression in patients wi
th brain pathologies.