Md. Stanton et Wr. Shadish, OUTCOME, ATTRITION, AND FAMILY-COUPLES TREATMENT FOR DRUG-ABUSE - A METAANALYSIS AND REVIEW OF THE CONTROLLED, COMPARATIVE-STUDIES, Psychological bulletin, 122(2), 1997, pp. 170-191
This review synthesizes drug abuse outcome studies that included a fam
ily-couples therapy treatment condition, The meta-analytic evidence, a
cross 1,571 cases involving an estimated 3,500 patients and family mem
bers, favors family therapy over (a) individual counseling or therapy,
(b) peer group therapy, and (c) family psychoeducation. Family therap
y is as effective for adults as for adolescents and appears to be a co
st-effective adjunct to methadone maintenance. Because family therapy
frequently had higher treatment retention rates than did nonfamily the
rapy modalities, it was modestly penalized in studies that excluded tr
eatment dropouts from their analyses, as family therapy apparently had
retained a higher proportion of poorer prognosis cases. Re-analysis,
with dropouts regarded as failures, generally offset this artifact. Tw
o statistical effect size measures to contend with attrition (dropout
d and total attrition d) are offered for future researchers and policy
makers.