Dt. Herron et Ea. Bates, SENTENTIAL AND ACOUSTIC FACTORS IN THE RECOGNITION OF OPEN-AND CLOSED-CLASS WORDS, Journal of memory and language, 37(2), 1997, pp. 217-239
Closed-class words are highly frequent yet relatively difficult to per
ceive; although this ought to impair communication, we communicate eas
ily under normal conditions. Modular and interactive architectures off
er differing explanations of this paradox, with different assumptions
about how the acoustic and grammatical properties of those words are c
ombined. The interaction of these factors was investigated by having s
ubjects listen for and repeat open-and closed-class homophones (spoken
by a male) that were spliced into three female-voice sentences: (a) t
he same sentence, (b) a neutral sentence, and (c) the ''swapped'' sent
ence (e.g., open-target in a closed-class context). Results show that:
(a) under neutral conditions, it is harder to identify closed- than o
pen-class tokens; but (b) they differ little in their original context
s; (c) open-class tokens are very easy to identify in a closed-class c
ontext; (d) recognizability of closed-class tokens in the swapped cont
ext was generally poor; and (e) these interactions are influenced by s
entence prosody but not by target length. It is argued that these resu
lts indicate a relatively early interaction between perceptual and con
textual processing. (C) 1997 Academic Press.