F. Favata et al., ON THE COMPARISON BETWEEN SPECTROSCOPIC AND PHOTOMETRIC METALLICITY MEASUREMENTS IN ACTIVE SOLAR-TYPE STARS, Astronomy and astrophysics, 324(3), 1997, pp. 998-1004
We present spectroscopic determinations of the Fe abundance in a sampl
e of K-type stars selected from the Xray flux-limited Einstein Extende
d Medium Sensitivity Survey. These stars have been shown to have a low
value of the m(1) Stromgren photometric index implying low metal abun
dances, similar to the abundance observed in Pop. II stars. Yet these
cool stars are not expected to be metal-poor being most likely young a
nd thus metal-rich. Based on an equivalent width-based abundance analy
sis which uses high resolution spectra in the region around the Li I 6
707.8 Angstrom doublet, we show that none of the stars investigated sh
ows any evidence for low metal abundances. Rather, all have solar or e
ven slightly super-solar abundances. Thus, for very active K stars, ph
otometric metallicity determinations appear to be strongly biased, wit
h the stars appearing to be of much lower metallicity than they actual
ly are. The stars in our sample are estimated to be coeval or younger
than those of the Pleiades. If, as we argue, the bias in the photometr
ic indices depends purely on the high activity level of these stars, i
t is then likely that all stars sufficiently young to have similar act
ivity levels would display similar photometric anomalies. We then pred
ict that a non-negligible fraction of the disk population K-type stars
are expected to show comparable anomalies in their photometric indice
s. These stars will masquerade as Pop. II stars in photometric surveys
, and significantly contaminate Pop. II star samples selected on the b
asis of photometric properties alone, down to quite faint magnitudes.