R. Hanna et al., EFFECTS OF PREDATION AND COMPETITION ON THE POPULATION-DYNAMICS OF TETRANYCHUS-PACIFICUS ON GRAPEVINES, Journal of Applied Ecology, 34(4), 1997, pp. 878-888
1, The Pacific spider mite Tetranychus pacificus and the Willamette sp
ider mite Eotetranychus willamettei are herbivore pests of grapevines
In California, The two spider mite species share a common and often ef
fective phytoseiid predator, the Western orchard predatory mite Metase
iulus occidentalis. It has been suggested that E. willamettei may be b
eneficial in vineyards because it may have a negative impact: an the m
ore damaging T, pacificus through their shared predator or through som
e form of interspecific competition, We conducted field and greenhouse
experiments to determine the relative effects of these interactions b
etween the two herbivores on the population dynamics of T, pacificus i
n 'Thompson Seedless' grape vineyards. We also used the field data to
generate a functional relationship for the combined impact of E. willa
mettei and M. occidentalis on T, pacificus. 2, Predation and predator-
mediated apparent competition were the only factors affecting T, pacif
icus densities in the field experiment, The addition of the predatory
mite M, occidentalis alone resulted in a significant reduction in T, p
acificus densities, while the addition of E, willamettei alone had lit
tle impact on T, pacificus densities. The greatest reductions in T. pa
cificus densities occurred in plots where both the predatory mite M, o
ccidentalis and E, willamettei were added, The predatory mite occurred
earliest and increased at the greatest rate in plots where it was rel
eased along with E. willamettei. From April to June, M. occidentalis a
bundance was positively correlated with E. willamettei abundance while
T. pacificus abundance in July and August was negatively correlated w
ith M. occidentalis abundance in the period April to June. 3, Under gr
eenhouse conditions, the addition of E. willamettei to T. pacificus vi
nes resulted in a marked decrease in T pacificus population growth rat
e. In contrast, doubling T. pacificus abundance in the absence E willa
mettei did not affect T. pacificus population growth rate, indicating
that interspecific competition is more important than intraspecific co
mpetition in determining T. pacificus abundance, 4, Contrary to the gr
eenhouse data and other studies in 'Zinfandel' vineyards, we found no
evidence that E, willamettei competed with T, pacificus in the absence
of predation in a Thompson Seedless vineyard. We suggest that the out
come of interactions between E, willamettei and T. pacificus may be af
fected by grape cultivar, growing region, a combination of cultivar an
d region-specific differences, or size and timing of vine infestations
with E, willamettei. 5, In Thompson Seedless vineyards, ville infesta
tion with E, willamettei would be most useful in increasing the effect
iveness of the predatory mite M. occidentalis in controlling T, pacifi
cus, primarily through an elevated predatory mite abundance prior to t
he development of large T, pacificus populations.