Ew. Allen, MEASURED TIME-DELAY AND RE-SYNCHRONIZATION TIME IN DIGITAL MICROWAVE RADIO SYSTEMS, IEEE transactions on power delivery, 9(2), 1994, pp. 639-644
The transition from analog to digital transmission systems has been sl
ower for Electric Power Utilities than other industrial sectors becaus
e of concern that digital transmission system delay times could advers
ely impact the response time of transfer trip protective relaying equi
pment. Alcatel Network Systems has completed a comprehensive testing p
rogram to measure the absolute time delay and various re-synchronizati
on times through analog and digital transmission systems. The general
conclusion is that the worst case absolute time delay of 577 microseco
nds, VF to VF, through the digital microwave system is approximately o
ne half the delay for a typical analog system. Absolute time delays of
500-600 microseconds should cause no problems to transfer trip protec
tive relaying systems. The re-synchronization times encountered after
any event that causes a break in the digital signal, such as the switc
hing of hot standby transmitters on microwave systems, are of tremendo
us concern to Electric Utilities. If a digital microwave system is des
igned using hot standby transmitters and the assumption is made that o
ne catastrophic event will cause simultaneous disruption of a power tr
ansmission line and the microwave transmission system, then the signal
disruption caused by switching hot standby transmitters must be taken
into account in the design of the protective relaying system. These r
e-synchronization times range from 11-19 milliseconds for a DS-1 inter
face to 32-45 milliseconds for a VF interface through the digital chan
nel banks.