Hn. Nigg et G. Radulescu, SCIENTIFIC MISCONDUCT IN ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE AND TOXICOLOGY, JAMA, the journal of the American Medical Association, 272(2), 1994, pp. 168-170
Scientific misconduct easily occurs in environmental science and toxic
ology; we encountered four such cases. Only one case was discovered by
editors; three were reported by other authors. All guilty authors wer
e eventually banned from future publication in the Bulletin of Environ
mental Contamination and Toxicology. Cases in the Bulletin indicate th
at scientific misconduct may occur undetected across phyla, genera, an
d species; that distance from the publishing source makes detection mo
re difficult; that editors and reviewers are not organized to take act
ion against scientific misconduct; that plagiarized authors are likely
to report plagiarism; and that there is only a small risk of censure
from any source for authors engaging in scientific misconduct.