Yd. Wu et Zh. Peng, THEORETICAL-STUDIES ON ALKENE ADDITION TO MOLYBDENUM ALKYLIDENES, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 119(34), 1997, pp. 8043-8049
The addition of ethene to Mo(NH)(CHR)(OR')(2) (R = H, Me; R' = CH3, CF
3) has been studied with both ab initio molecular orbital and density
functional theory calculations. Geometry optimizations were carried ou
t with the HF/3-21G, HF/HW3, and B3LYP/HW3 methods. The energies were
further evaluated with the MP2/HW3 and B3LYP/HWF (HWF basis set is equ
ivalent to the 6-311G* basis set) methods. Ethene significantly favor
s attacking on the CNO face. The attack on the COO face by ethene is d
isfavored by 12.3 and 18.8 kcal/mol for R' = CH3 and CF3, respectively
. The transition structure for the CNO face addition is in a distorted
trigonal bipyramidal geometry, with the NH and one of the OR' groups
axial. The calculated activation energy is low for R' = CH3, and it is
significantly lower for R' = CF3. In agreement with the experiment, t
he syn alkylidene is calculated to be more stable than the anti rotame
r (R = CH3). This is apparently due to the stabilizing agostic interac
tion involving the anti-a of the syn rotamer on the COO face. However,
the transition structures derived from the syn and anti rotamers have
similar stabilities, due to the disappearance of the agostic interact
ion. Thus, the anti alkylidene is effectively a more reactive catalyst
than the syn alkylidene. The molybdacyclobutane product significantly
favors a square pyramidal geometry when R' = CH3, but has a slight pr
eference for a trigonal bipyramidal geometry when R' = CF3.