AIR-POLLUTION IN SWITZERLAND - QUANTIFICA TION OF HEALTH-EFFECTS AND USE OF EPIDEMIOLOGIC DATA
Citation
N. Kunzli et al., AIR-POLLUTION IN SWITZERLAND - QUANTIFICA TION OF HEALTH-EFFECTS AND USE OF EPIDEMIOLOGIC DATA, Schweizerische medizinische Wochenschrift, 127(34), 1997, pp. 1361-1370
Categorie Soggetti
Medicine, General & Internal
SICI code
0036-7672(1997)127:34<1361:AIS-QT>2.0.ZU;2-6
Abstract
Public health costs ascribable to air pollution are socialized in our
society. To quantify the damage to public health, epidemiologic studie
s are needed. We present the methods and epidemiologic background data
which form the basis for estimating the public health effect ascribab
le to air pollution. The figures are presented per 1 million ''average
'' Swiss population and per 10 mu g/m(3) increase in long-term annual
mean particulate pollution (PM10). Quantification was restricted to th
e health effects given below (due to lack of complete data for other e
ffects or to avoid duplicating health effects which may be described b
y overlapping measurements). In parenthesis we present (1) the mean ef
fect estimates (+/-1 SE) (% increase per 10 mu g/m(3) increment in PM1
0) derived from national and international epidemiologic studies, and
(2) the expected absolute additional health effects (+/-1 SE) per 1 mi
llion Swiss population and per 10 mu g/m(3) increment in PM10, based o
n Swiss population statistics: total mortality (long-term estimates fr
om the 2 US cohort studies) (+4.4% [+/-1.1] / 349 [+/-91] premature de
aths per year); prevalence of chronic bronchitis in adults (+/-25% [+8
.4] increase in long-term prevalence by 3,513 [+/-1.475]); bronchitis
among children (35% [+/-13] / 5,180 [+/-2,590] additional children suf
ferers in a year); repeated cough among children (+54% [+/-8.8] / 23,4
90 [+/-5,873] additional children per year); cough/phlegm in adults (12.8% [+/-7.8] / 1.56 [+/-1.08] million person-days per year); hospita
l admissions for respiratory diseases (+/-1.47% [+/-0.5] / 71 [+/-24]
additional admissions or 1,104 (+/-390) hospital days); admissions for
cardiovascular diseases (+0.9% [+/-0.25] / 70 [+19] admissions; 970 (
+/-270) hospital days); restricted activity days (+10.5% [+/-0.77] / 0
.42 [+/-0.03] million person-days); days with asthma attacks among the
6.7% asthmatics (Swiss prevalence) (+5.3% [+/-2.1] / 240,000 [+/-102,
000] additional person-days). Conservative assumptions were used throu
ghout the study and thus the true effects are likely to be larger. Est
imates of Swiss population exposure distribution would be needed to ap
ply these results to the entire population. This step, and monetary qu
antification of these total effects, were the second and third element
s (not shown in this report) of this Swiss government funded project.
Although individual relative risks of air pollution are rather slight,
the public health burden of even moderate pollution may be substantia
l.