The long-term (5-yr) responses of plant absolute abundance and species
diversity to N, P, and N+P fertilization were investigated in two sed
ge-dominated alpine plant communities that differed in soil resource a
vailability but not in macroclimate: a resource-poor dry meadow and a
more resource-rich wet meadow. Prior to analysis, species were grouped
into functional groups based on growth form, potential developmental
constraints, and presence or absence of mutualisms. Absolute abundance
changes of functional groups were more pronounced in the dry-meadow c
ommunity than in the wet-meadow community. In the dry meadow, mycorrhi
zal forbs increased with N+P fertilization, nonmycorrhizal forbs incre
ased with P and N+P, and N-2-fixing forbs increased with P alone. Gras
ses increased with N and N+P, whereas sedges, the dominant functional
group, were unaffected by fertilization. In the wet meadow, the domina
nt sedges exhibited abundance increases in response to N, whereas gras
ses increased with P and N+P. Wet-meadow forb abundance was not signif
icantly influenced by fertilization. Shifts in relative abundances of
species resulted in an increase in species diversity following N+P fer
tilization in the dry meadow, and a decrease in species diversity foll
owing N+P fertilization in the wet meadow. This study, therefore, allo
wed a direct comparison of diversity responses between communities tha
t differed primarily in soil resource availability, substantiating the
theory that plant species diversity is greatest under intermediate le
vels of fertility.