Clearing material from nuclear installations is a well established pra
ctice in Germany. The material specific clearance criteria used in Ger
many have been derived from radiological assessments that necessarily
involve a certain degree of conservativity in order not to underestima
te possible doses. These material specific criteria show undesirable d
ifferences in the level of radiological protection they offer. Therefo
re the degree of conservativity involved in deriving the clearance cri
teria was evaluated and compared In this article the clearance criteri
a for conventional disposal of slightly radioactive waste are compared
with the well established criteria for clearance of metal scrap from
nuclear power plants, which represent a level of generally accepted co
nservativity. Such comparisons can be used to harmonize the various cl
earance criteria. Although before well established clearance criteria
ar-e changed careful consideration regarding the economical and radiol
ogical benefits should be made.