Yh. Song, THE CANADA-EUROPEAN-UNION TURBOT DISPUTE IN THE NORTHWEST ATLANTIC - AN APPLICATION OF THE INCIDENT APPROACH, Ocean development and international law, 28(3), 1997, pp. 269-311
Fisheries disputes, such as the recent one between Canada and the Euro
pean Union (EU) over the right to fish on the high seas of the Northwe
st Atlantic, if handled badly, can escalate into armed conflict. The C
anada-EU turbot dispute has shown that there is an urgent need to reso
lve the conflicts between distant water fishing states' right to fish
under the traditional freedom of the high seas and the coastal state's
interest in the conservation and management of fishery resources beyo
nd and adjacent to its exclusive economic zone under customary and con
ventional international law. The incident approach is used to examine
the dispute. The problems and facts relating to the dispute are provid
ed, the conflicting claims and the legal norms cited by the concerned
parties to support respective claims are identified and the internatio
nal reactions to the dispute are described and analysed. The author su
ggests that the incident was a part of Canada's overall strategy for e
nhancing its interest in protecting fish stocks beyond its 200-mile ex
clusive fishing zone.