Tw. Teasdale et A. Engberg, DURATION OF COGNITIVE DYSFUNCTION AFTER CONCUSSION, AND COGNITIVE DYSFUNCTION AS A RISK FACTOR - A POPULATION STUDY OF YOUNG MEN, BMJ. British medical journal, 315(7108), 1997, pp. 569-572
Objectives: To establish how long cognitive dysfunction lasts after co
ncussion, and the extent to which it may be a predisposing risk factor
for concussion, by examining the prevalence of cognitive dysfunction
among young men who have sustained concussion. Design: Observational s
tudy. Setting: Denmark. Subjects: 1220 young men who had been admitted
to hospital for concussion between the ages of 16 and 24 (identified
in a national register of admissions) and who had also been cognitivel
y tested by the Danish conscription draft board.Main outcome measure:
Score on the draft board's cognitive screening test, dichotomised as d
ysfunctional or non-dysfunctional (20.4% of the general population of
Danish men appearing before the draft board had a dysfunctional score)
. Results: 700 of the 1220 men had been tested after sustaining concus
sion; 520 had been tested before concussion. Four (50%) of the eight m
en who were tested less than seven days after the injury had a dysfunc
tional score. Among groups of the remaining 692 men who were tested at
later time points after injury, the rates were only marginally raised
(range 21.4% to 26.5%) above the population level. Among men tested b
efore injury, the rate of dysfunctional scores was higher (30.4% (158/
520)). Apart from suggesting cognitive dysfunction as a risk factor fo
r concussion, this higher proportion seems to relate to the fact that
they were typically injured as young adults, whereas those men who wer
e tested after concussion had more often been injured as adolescents.
The relative risk for concussion in the presence of cognitive dysfunct
ion is estimated to be 1.57 (95% confidence interval 1.32 to 1.86). Co
nclusions: Cognitive dysfunction is not only a short term consequence
of concussion but also a predisposing risk factor for concussion, more
so for young adults than for adolescents.