Single-point solutions to the horizontal momentum equation (describing
tidal propagation) are used to illustrate the influence of both botto
m friction and vertical eddy viscosity. These influences determine whe
ther a simplified vertically-averaged, two-dimensional model will adeq
uately simulate tidal propagation, or where a fully three-dimensional
model is required. The effective influences of these two terms is sens
itive to both latitude and tidal frequency, in addition to current spe
ed and water depth - thus complicating the a-priori selection of a 2-D
or 3-D model. The present study shows that, for applications concerne
d primarily with prediction of water levels and depth-integrated tidal
fluxes, 2-D models are generally entirely adequate in water depths ex
ceeding 50 m-a consequence of small frictional influence. However, exc
eptions to this conclusion may arise at latitudes corresponding to the
inertial frequencies, i.e. lambda>70 degrees for semi-diurnal constit
uents and 27 degrees less than or equal to lambda less than or equal t
o 30 degrees for diurnal constituents. Analytical solutions can be use
d to augment 2-D model results providing reliable qualitative descript
ions of variations in current profiles. However, for applications wher
e detailed current profiles are important, including accurate represen
tation of the near-bed velocity and associated erosional stress, 3-D m
odels with detailed descriptions of turbulence structure are required.
The use of 3-D models for shallow estuaries and bays should avoid the
necessity of empirical adjustment to the dissipation processes that a
re poorly represented by a quadratic-type law based on depth-averaged
velocities. The above conclusions apply to the propagation of tides in
the absence of pronounced effects of wind forcing or density gradient
s. (C) 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd.