We use L-2 methods to show that if a group with a presentation of defi
ciency one is an extension of Z by a finitely generated normal subgrou
p then the 2-complex corresponding to any presentation of optimal defi
ciency is aspherical and to prove a converse of the Cheeger-Gromov-Got
tlieb theorem relating Euler characteristic and asphericity. These res
ults are applied to the Whitehead conjecture, 4-manifolds and 2-knot g
roups.