R. Marchant et al., CLASSIFICATION AND PREDICTION OF MACROINVERTEBRATE ASSEMBLAGES FROM RUNNING WATERS IN VICTORIA, AUSTRALIA, Journal of the North American Benthological Society, 16(3), 1997, pp. 664-681
We constructed predictive models using 2 macroinvertebrate data sets (
for both species and family) from bankside habitats at 49 undisturbed
reference sites from 6 Victorian river basins; data were accumulated o
ver 4 to 6 sampling occasions. Classification (by unweighted pair-grou
p arithmetic averaging with the Bray-Curtis association measure) showe
d 3 site groups were evident at the species level and 4 at the family
level. A subset of 5 of 22 environmental variables provided maximum di
scrimination (using stepwise discriminant analysis) between the 3 spec
ies site groups; these variables were: conductivity, altitude, substra
te heterogeneity, distance of a site from source, and longitude. Four
variables discriminated between the 4 family site groups: conductivity
, catchment area upstream of site, mean annual discharge and latitude.
From the discriminant analysis, it was possible to predict the group
into which an unknown site (specified only by measurements on the 4 or
5 variables just noted) would be placed and thus the probabilities of
occurrence of taxa at this site. To test predictive ability, 4 sites
were removed at random from the 2 data sets and the classification and
discriminant models were recalculated. This process was repeated 5 ti
mes. The identity and number of taxa observed at each of these sites w
ere compared with those predicted with a probability of occurrence >50
% and the results expressed as a ratio of numbers observed to numbers
expected (O/E). This ratio varied from 0.75 to 1.05 at the species lev
el and from 0.83 to 1.12 at the family level, indicating that the faun
a conformed with expectation (O/E near 1.0). To test such predictive m
odels on independent data, O/E ratios were also calculated for family
data collected in spring at 18 sites from a basin not used in the orig
inal models. Two new discriminant models based on single sets of sampl
es from the reference sites taken in spring were constructed for this
purpose. O/E ratios varied from 0.09 to 1.01 for the 18 sites and were
inversely correlated (r = -0.4 to -0.8) with a range of water quality
variables, the values of which increased as water quality deteriorate
d. The O/E ratio could thus be considered a sensitive measure of distu
rbance.