Pr. Bierman, USING IN-SITU PRODUCED COSMOGENIC ISOTOPES TO ESTIMATE RATES OF LANDSCAPE EVOLUTION - A REVIEW FROM THE GEOMORPHIC PERSPECTIVE, J GEO R-SOL, 99(B7), 1994, pp. 13885-13896
The application of in-situ produced cosmogenic isotopes to problems in
geomorphology has increased rapidly over the past decade. At least 57
papers and numerous abstracts have been published since the mid-1980s
when the first mass-spectrometric measurements of terrestrially produ
ced cosmogenic isotopes were made. Taken at face value, these studies
provide quantitative information about rates of landscape evolution an
d landform age; however, the significance of calculated erosion rates
and exposure ages depends strongly on the models used to interpret iso
topic data, the validity of assumptions inherent to these models, and
the geologic surroundings in which the samples were collected. This pa
per attempts to place cosmogenic isotope studies in a geomorphic conte
xt by reviewing fundamentals of the method and evaluating the validity
of assumptions under which these data have been interpreted. At prese
nt, the establishment of high-precision, cosmogenically based glacial
and alluvial chronologies is stymied by the evolution of geomorphic su
rfaces, the erosion of rock from sampled boulders, the potential for i
sotope inheritance from previous exposure, and the uncertainty of isot
opic measurements. Uncertainties in isotope production rates and die o
bserved variability of exposure ages on individual geomorphic surfaces
limit the confidence with which cosmogenic ages can be correlated rel
iably with those obtained by other techniques. Estimation of erosion r
ates at single points on the landscape gives useful small-scale inform
ation. Extrapolation of these rates over longer time and larger spatia
l scales is less sure and most likely biased toward lower erosion rate
s by the inadvertent selection of resistant sample sites. However, bec
ause erosion rates are so poorly constrained at present, even estimate
s to within a factor of 2 may be of significant value to geomorphologi
sts and tectonicists.