Measurements of intracellular, cytosolic Al are plagued with technical
difficulties. An accurate quantification of Al uptake into the cytoso
l relies on the effectiveness of the methods that desorb Al bound to t
he cell wall. However, published desorption methods are not completely
effective in removing cell wall Al. Using giant algal cells of Chara
corallina, where a physical separation of the cell wall and the cytoso
l can be achieved surgically, it was shown that up to 99.99% of the to
tal cellular Al accumulates in the cell wall. Even when 95% of total A
l present in intact cells was desorbed, still over 20 times more Al wa
s left in the cell wall than in the cytosol. Therefore, without physic
al separation of the cell wall and the cytosol, minute amounts of cyto
solic Al need to be measured in the considerably larger background of
the cell wall Al. Consequently, up to several orders of magnitude lowe
r uptake rates of Al were measured across the plasma membrane of intac
t Chara cells in comparison to currently available values on higher pl
ant cells (Triticum aestivum, Glycine max, Phaseolus vulgaris), where
at least some of the cell wall Al was attributed to the intracellular,
cytosolic Al. Uptake of Al across the plasma membrane of Chara cells
occurs without a delay at a very low rate that is directly proportiona
l to Al concentration in the uptake medium. Moreover, residual Al left
in the cell wall after desorption can be taken up into the cytosol of
Chara cells during subsequent growth in the artificial pond water. Fo
r measuring Al uptake into roots of higher plants, the Secondary Ion M
ass Spectrometry is the best available technique because it appears to
overestimate the cytosolic Al to the lower extent than any other curr
ently used analytical method for determination of Al.