Dp. Stevens et al., PHYTOTOXICITY OF ALUMINUM-FLUORIDE COMPLEXES AND THEIR UPTAKE FROM SOLUTION CULTURE BY AVENA-SATIVA AND LYCOPERSICON-ESCULENTUM, Plant and soil, 192(1), 1997, pp. 81-93
Avena sativa (oats) and Lycopersicon esculentum (tomatoes) were grown
in dilute nutrient solutions supplemented with Al only, F only or a co
mbination of both. In solutions containing Al and F, shoot growth was
limited when predicted Al-r (Al3+, AlOH2+ and Al(OH)(2)(+)) activities
were < 0.1 mu M, activities three orders of magnitude lower than the
critical value determined with Al only. The data suggest that at the a
ctivities used in these experiments, Al-r is most toxic, AlF2+ and AlF
2+ are toxic to a lesser extent, and AlF3, AlF4- and F- are least toxi
c. Fluoride concentrations in shoots grown in solutions correlated bes
t with positively charged AlFx3-x species (i.e. AlF2+ AlF2+) and the m
olar ratio of F:AI in most plants shoots was about 3:2. However, when
activities of positively charged AIF(x)(3-x) species were low (< 50 mu
M) and the activity of AlF3 species high (500 mu M the molar ratio of
F:Al in plant shoots suggested AlF3 was taken up. These findings are
discussed in relation to plant uptake and toxicity. Measured concentra
tions of Al-r and F- in solutions containing Al and F were compared wi
th concentrations predicted by a computer model (GEOCHEM-PC). The meth
od for measuring F- concentrations, using a noncomplexing buffer and F
ion-selective electrode, gave good agreement with predicted F-concent
rations. The 8-hydroxyquinoline method for measuring Al-r concentratio
ns did not agree with predicted concentrations, highlighting the limit
ations of this method when measuring Al-r in the presence of F in a mu
lti-ligand system with high concentrations of F and Al.