In this article, it is shown that the case for using optimal signal-ex
traction filters is not all that convincing once it is recognized that
seasonal adjustment is typically not the only transformation applied
to data. Seasonal adjustment is viewed as any general linear filter. A
ll other data transformations are also assumed to be linear. Although
optimal filters always dominate uniform filters, their dominance criti
cally depends on performing seasonal adjustment and the other data tra
nsformations in the right sequence. The conclusions of our article mak
e a strong case in favor of the wide practice uf uniform filtering.