Ab. Woodland et al., INTERSITE PARTITIONING OF MG AND FE IN CA-FREE HIGH-PRESSURE C2 C CLINOPYROXENE/, The American mineralogist, 82(9-10), 1997, pp. 923-930
The intracrystalline distribution of Mg and Fe2+ on the M1 and M2 octa
hedral sites in high-P C2/c (Mg,Fe)SiO3 clinopyroxene has been determi
ned on quenched samples using Fe-57 Mossbauer spectroscopy. Although t
he recovered samples that were measured had the low-P (P2(1)/c) struct
ure, the ordering state of the high-P polymorph is believed to have be
en preserved because the high-P C2/c --> low-P P2(1)/c transformation
occurred at room temperature during the final stages of decompression
of the experiments. Under such conditions significant cation diffusion
is unlikely. Low temperature (81 K) Mossbauer spectra indicate that F
e2+ is strongly ordered onto the M2 sites, with an average K-D Angstro
m 4.0(8) for the intersite exchange reaction: Fe2+(M1) + Mg2+(M2) = Fe
2+(M2) + Mg2+(M1) (1) Because the samples were quenched from high temp
erature (1200-1275 degrees C) at 9.5 GPa, the temperature to which the
measured ordering state corresponds remains problematic. However, a s
ample re-annealed at 1000 degrees C is more ordered than the original
sample synthesized at 1275 degrees C, suggesting that high-temperature
cation distributions in high-P clinopyroxene can be quenched in the m
ulti-anvil experiments. Therefore, we conclude that the measured catio
n distributions correspond approximately to the conditions of the expe
riments. A small compositional dependence of cation ordering also exis
ts, indicating subregular behavior across the binary join. A fit to th
e data yields Delta G(exch)degrees = -11.9 (2.0) kJ/mol at 1275 degree
s C for the exchange Reaction 1, which describes the ordering behavior
on the octahedral sites in the clinopyroxenes. Comparison with data f
or orthopyroxene, which were obtained mostly at 1 atm, indicates that
the state of ordering in orthopyroxene and high-P clinopyroxene is sim
ilar, especially if cation ordering in the high-P clinopyroxene has a
small pressure dependence. The similarities are consistent with the ob
served structural similarities between the two polymorphs.