La. Hirschfeld et Sa. Gelman, WHAT YOUNG-CHILDREN THINK ABOUT THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN LANGUAGE VARIATION AND SOCIAL DIFFERENCE, Cognitive development, 12(2), 1997, pp. 213-238
Previous work suggests that preschoolers understand that members of so
me social groups (e.g., based on occupation or gender) speak in distin
ct ways, but do not understand that members of other social groups (e.
g., based on race, culture, or nationality) speak different languages.
In these four studies we explored preschool children's inferences abo
ut language and social group membership. In Study 1 we found that pres
choolers believed that minority race individuals, people wearing unfam
iliar clothing, or people living in unfamiliar dwellings were more lik
ely to speak an unfamiliar foreign language than to speak English. Stu
dies 2A and 2B showed that children do not map social group difference
s to language for all social categories. Specifically, children were m
ore likely to attribute language differences to racial rather than age
differences and were more likely to map differences in music preferen
ce onto age than racial differences. Results of Study 3 showed childre
n's inferences about language and social group differences were not de
rived from differences in intelligibility. Study 4 provides insight in
to why children readily make these language to social kind mappings by
identifying a common property that both broad social kinds and distin
ct languages are thought to share. Together these studies provide evid
ence that even preschoolers may be coordinating knowledge across conte
nt domains in a coherent and meaningful way that underwrites the proje
ction of existing knowledge to unknown instances.