Advertising folklore has it that creative department people have diffi
culty connecting to their mass media audiences. This article describes
research in which creatives and a general sample of viewers responded
personally to a range of commercials. Comparing them, creative people
responded positively to award-winning commercials (One Show and EFFIE
winners); viewers responded positively to advertising that led to fee
lings of personal enhancement, whether award winners or not. This find
ing means that creatives respond to advertising that meets professiona
l rather than audience-communication criteria. In turn this implies th
at creative people produce work that primarily meets professional stan
dards which can differ from those of communicating and selling to the
audience. Suggestions are offered to alleviate this situation.