Ms. Taylor et al., DUE-PROCESS IN PERFORMANCE-APPRAISAL - A QUASI-EXPERIMENT IN PROCEDURAL JUSTICE, Administrative science quarterly, 40(3), 1995, pp. 495-523
This field experiment extended research on procedural justice by exami
ning effects of a due-process performance appraisal system on reaction
s of both employees and managers. Employee-manager pairs were randomly
assigned to either a due-process appraisal system or the existing sys
tem. Even though due-process employees received lower evaluations, the
y displayed more favorable reactions: perceived system fairness, appra
isal accuracy, attitudes toward the system, evaluations of managers, a
nd intention to remain with the organization. Managers also responded
positively, reporting greater ability to resolve work problems, satisf
action with the system, job satisfaction, and less distortion of appra
isal results to further their own self-interests.