The pinning effects and the critical current density predicted to occu
r in bulk YBa2Cu3O from second phase particles and from dislocations a
re examined. It is shown that core or strain pinning by dislocations p
rovides the best explanation of pinning forces, and that strain pinnin
g by dislocations or particle pinning of individual (but not multiple)
flux lines best fit the pinning energy. An experiment in which critic
al current is increased when particles are coarsened by long molten ho
lding times during melt processing is correlated with increased disloc
ation density, despite a drop in volume fraction and increase in size
of the added normal state particles. The combined aspects of these sug
gest that strain induced pinning from dislocations may be the dominant
mechanism in high critical current bulk materials.