Ae. Black et al., HUMAN ENERGY-EXPENDITURE IN AFFLUENT SOCIETIES - AN ANALYSIS OF 574 DOUBLY-LABELED WATER MEASUREMENTS, European journal of clinical nutrition, 50(2), 1996, pp. 72-92
Objectives: To describe average levels of free-living energy expenditu
re in people from affluent societies and to determine the influence of
body weight, height, age and sex. Design: Analysis of 574 measurement
s of total energy expenditure (TEE, assessed by the doubly-labelled wa
ter method); basal metabolic rate (BMR, directly measured or derived f
rom similar directly measured proxy measures such as during sleep); ac
tivity energy expenditure (AEE, derived as TEE - BMR); and physical ac
tivity level (PAL, derived as TEE/BMR) from people aged 2-95 years. Th
e dataset was extracted from 1614 published and unpublished measuremen
ts in 1156 subjects after exclusion of repeat estimates and subjects i
n special physiological or behavioural states (eg pregnancy, athletic
or military training etc). Results: A separate analysis of data from n
on-ambulant subjects, and from elite endurance athletes (ail excluded
from the main dataset) established the limits of human daily energy ex
penditure at around 1.2 x BMR and 4.5 x BMR. In the main analysis, the
validity of PAL as an index of TEE adjusted for BMR was tested and co
nfirmed. Regression equations were then derived to describe TEE, BMR,
AEE and PAL in terms of body weight, height, age and sex. As anticipat
ed, TEE, BMR and AEE were all positively related to weight and height,
while age was a negative predictor, especially of activity. The influ
ence of weight disappeared when TEE was expressed as PAL, but height a
nd age remained as highly significant predictors. For all three compon
ents, females expended 11% less energy on average than males after adj
ustment for weight, height and age. Average levels of energy expenditu
re in different age and sex groups are tabulated. Conclusions: There n
ow exists a large and robust database of energy expenditure measuremen
ts obtained by the doubly-labelled water method. Analysis of the data
from affluent societies shows that, in general, levels of energy expen
diture are similar to the recommendations for energy requirements adop
ted by FAO/WHO/UNU (1985) and UK Department of Health (1991). PAL valu
es for active subjects tend to be higher than is currently assumed. Th
e current analysis provides a substantial body of normal data against
which other estimates can be compared. Sponsorship: Supported by the M
edical Research Council. Descriptors: basal metabolic rate, doubly-lab
elled water method, energy expenditure, physical activity level