Jk. Klingner et S. Vaughn, RECIPROCAL TEACHING OF READING-COMPREHENSION STRATEGIES FOR STUDENTS WITH LEARNING-DISABILITIES WHO USE ENGLISH AS A 2ND LANGUAGE, The Elementary school journal, 96(3), 1996, pp. 275-293
In this study, we investigated the efficacy of 2 related interventions
on the reading comprehension of seventh and eighth graders with learn
ing disabilities who used English as a second language. All 26 student
s participated in reciprocal teaching for 15 days and then were random
ly assigned for 12 days to 1 of 2 groups: reciprocal teaching with coo
perative grouping (n = 13) or reciprocal teaching with cross-age tutor
ing (n = 13). Though there were no statistically significant differenc
es between groups on 2 measures of comprehension, students in both gro
ups made significant progress in reading comprehension. Analyses focus
ed on understanding the performance of more and less successful studen
ts within groups. Findings revealed that initial reading ability and o
ral language proficiency seemed related to gains in comprehension, tha
t a greater range of students benefited from strategy instruction than
would have been predicted on the basis of previous research, and that
students in both groups continued to show improvement in comprehensio
n when provided minimal adult support.