Previous research has suggested that managers punish grievance filers
by giving them lower performance ratings and terminating their employm
ent. A 2-factor between-subjects design (N = 157) was used to examine
to what extent these ''punishment'' effects reflect an actual change i
n grievants' behavior. Consistent with procedural justice literature,
participants who had access to a grievance system were more willing to
continue working for the organization. Consistent with a motivation t
heory, participants who had a basis for dispute had lower objective jo
b performance and were less willing to continue working for the organi
zation. In contrast to previous research, the results provide some sup
port for the exit-voice model. In addition, the results suggest that p
art of the punishment effects reported in earlier field studies may be
due to an actual decrease in the grievants' objective job performance
.