Kj. White et al., CHILDRENS PERCEPTIONS OF BEHAVIOR PROBLEM PEERS - EFFECTS OF TEACHER FEEDBACK AND PEER-REPUTED STATUS, Journal of school psychology, 34(1), 1996, pp. 53-72
In a Reputation X Feedback X Actor type (3 X 3 X 3) design, we examine
d the influence of teacher feedback on children's evaluations of a hyp
othetical peer presented as having one of three reputations. The subje
cts (91 first and second graders) listened to an audiotape in which tw
o boys described five hypothetical peers. Reputation information (like
d, neutral, disliked) varied for only one of the actors (the target);
the others were described in neutral terms. Then the subjects watched
a videotape of the five boys in a classroom scene. In the video, two a
ctors exhibited behavior consistent with that of rejected, behavior pr
oblem children; the three other actors behaved appropriately. Teacher
feedback to one of the behavior problem actors (target) varied across
three conditions: (a) positive, (b) neutral, and (c) derogatory feedba
ck. Analyses specific to the target actor revealed a significant effec
t of feedback, with no effect of reputation or its interaction with fe
edback. Feedback produced differential perceptions of the target actor
across feedback conditions and had a discriminative influence on the
subjects' perceptions of the other actors. Methodological improvements
of the reputation manipulation and implications for classroom interve
ntion are discussed.