M. Hofer, SYMMETRIES AND ASYMMETRIES IN PLANNING INTERACTIONS OF MOTHER-DAUGHTER DYADS, Zeitschrift fur Padagogische Psychologie, 10(1), 1996, pp. 49-60
The contribution aims at the description of verbal interactions betwee
n mothers and adolescent daughters in a planning task, Individuation t
heoretic notions were considered to categorize and analyze the utteran
ces. It was hypothesized that mother-daughter relationships during ado
lescence are characterized by complementarity as well as by reciprocit
y. If features of relationship quality are manifested in terms of beha
vior in social interactions, complementarity should be indicated by an
asymmetry of interactional behaviors whereas reciprocity should be in
dicated by symmetry. 80 mothers and their adolescent daughters (ages 1
1-20) participated in interactions elicited by a planning task. Based
on literal transcripts, units of the conversations were identified and
coded according to 14 codes based on an instrument introduced by Grot
evant & Cooper (1985) which was constructed within an individuation th
eoretic framework. Two aspects of asymmetry were analyzed: (a) uneven
distribution of frequencies of a given code for mothers and daughters;
(b) differences in contingencies of responses to partners' initiative
s. As to the first aspect, findings mostly pointed to asymmetry, namel
y maternal dominance. As to the second aspect, the data rather suggest
ed a symmetrical relationship. Cluster analyses served to determine gr
oups varying in terms of symmetry. The most numerous group was charact
erized by clearly symmetrical patterns of mother-daughter interactions
. The dyads of the clusters, though, could not be discriminated by que
stionnaire variables measuring the quality of relationship. The result
s largely show that theoretical notions of the quality of parent-child
relationships during adolescence are a useful tool to describe verbal
interactions.