Previous experimental work has discovered several high performing heur
istic strategies in the search for the most economic price of a good,
in situations where the purchaser has partial prior knowledge of the p
rice distribution. It appeared previously, however, that individuals d
o not use a given search rule consistently. This paper describes a mod
ified experimental framework that investigates this apparent inconsist
ency in search behaviour. Results are analysed at the individual level
rather than in aggregate. The paper concludes that individuals do ado
pt consistent strategies subject to certain identified caveats. It is
suggested that inconsistent behaviour is associated with decision diff
iculty, very low search costs, and subjects' intellectual ability. Mor
eover, it concludes that the strategy most frequently adopted is fairl
y crude and is not the best performing one.