Ee. Wein, FOODS AND NUTRIENTS IN REPORTED DIETS VERSUS PERCEIVED IDEAL DIETS OFYUKON-INDIAN PEOPLE, Journal of nutrition education, 28(4), 1996, pp. 202-208
A common belief among northern aboriginal people is that they would en
joy better health if their diet contained a greater proportion of indi
genous foods. The accuracy of this belief was examined among 121 adult
s of three Yukon First Nations,living in remote and urban communities,
by comparing mean nutrient levels in a fall season 24-hour recall of
actual food consumption with those in a quantitative one day's descrip
tion of their perceived ideal diet for health. The latter was obtained
immediately following the 24-hour recall using a similar interviewing
technique. Graduated three-dimensional food models were used to estim
ate portion sizes. Compared to the actual diet, the perceived ideal di
et mentioned traditional foods about twice as often and provided, on a
verage, 245 more kcal and higher levels of most nutrients (p < .05), a
lthough the percentage of energy from fat was the same. The perceived
ideal diet met health recommendations for more nutrients than the actu
al diet; nevertheless, for both men and women, calcium remained below
the recommendation, while folate remained below the recommendation for
men. Energy from fat (34%) was higher than recommended. Implications
of results are discussed for nutrition education in aboriginal communi
ties.