Ms. Atkins et Mm. Mckay, DSM-IV DIAGNOSIS OF CONDUCT DISORDER AND OPPOSITIONAL DEFIANT DISORDER - IMPLICATIONS AND GUIDELINES FOR SCHOOL MENTAL-HEALTH TEAMS, School psychology review, 25(3), 1996, pp. 274-283
The DSM-IV criteria for conduct disorder (CD) and oppositional defiant
disorder (ODD) are reviewed. These diagnoses are compared with their
counterparts in DSM-III-R, and the rationale and empirical support for
changes in criteria are described. Generally, DSM-IV criteria appear
better operationalized and more closely conform to empirical studies t
han do prior criteria. However, results from DSM-IV field trials indic
ate that interrater and test-retest reliability were only marginally i
mproved compared to prior criteria and remained moderately low by psyc
hometric standards. Studies confirming the importance of subtyping CD
on age of onset are reviewed, and empirical evidence for the relations
hip between ODD and early-onset CD is described. These criteria highli
ght the importance of alerting clinicians to early intervention, espec
ially for symptoms of ODD that are typically easier to modify than one
s of CD. Although overlooked in DSM-IV criteria, community factors, ge
nder differences, and academic functioning are important consideration
s in school-based assessments and interventions.