G. Yair, SCHOOL ORGANIZATION AND MARKET ECOLOGY - A REALIST SOCIOLOGICAL LOOK AT THE INFRASTRUCTURE OF SCHOOL CHOICE, British journal of sociology of education, 17(4), 1996, pp. 453-471
Programs of school choice are based largely on the idea of a free mark
et: Recent reform efforts have been based on the assumption that marke
t-driven educational systems would bring higher achievement levels and
greater satisfaction among clients. According to popular views, paren
ts would shop for a school just as they do for any other commodity and
competition between schools would ensue, with each school trying to i
mprove itself thereby attracting consumers. There is a major drawback
to this reasoning. Markets are rarely completely free from regulation
and control, and the desires of individuals do not fully explain the s
ocial facts of school choice. As a complement to cut-rent school choic
e studies, a structural explanation of school choice within the theory
of network analysis is presented. The study analyses choice in terms
of inter-school student transfers and explains choice as the combined
result of two factors. The first is the organization of student mobili
ty in schools, in terms of vacant vacant positions (timing and volume)
and student body composition, which posits nine ideal types of school
organization. The second factor is the ecology of the market, given i
n the number of schools in each type. Research conducted in a large ci
ty in Israel serves as an example for the approach. The more general i
mplications of the study suggest directions for the theoretical refine
ment of mobility and attainment studies in sociology.