Na. King et al., EFFECTS OF SHORT-TERM EXERCISE ON APPETITE RESPONSES IN UNRESTRAINED FEMALES, European journal of clinical nutrition, 50(10), 1996, pp. 663-667
Objective: To examine the short-term effects of exercise and diet comp
osition on appetite in unrestrained females. Design: A 2 x 2 repeated
measures design study was conducted, with exercise and lunch type as t
he repeated factors. Setting: The Human Appetite Research Unit at Leed
s University Psychology department. Subjects: 13 unrestrained, normal
weight females were recruited from the student and staff population of
Leeds University. Interventions: Subjects were assigned to four exper
imental treatments in a counterbalanced order. These were a control (n
o-exercise) session and an intense (70% VO2 max) exercise session foll
owed by a free-selection test lunch consisting of high-fat/low-carbohy
drate or low-fat/high-carbohydrate foods. The effects of exercise and
lunch type were measured by monitoring energy intake and macronutrient
intake during the test lunches only. Visual analogue scales were used
to monitor profiles of motivation to eat during the treatments. Resul
ts: Subjects did not experience the marked suppression of hunger induc
ed by exercise, which is a striking and robust finding in men. Moreove
r, unlike men, females rated a range of foods to be more palatable aft
er exercise (F(1,12)=8.0, P<0.05). Similar to male subjects, exercise
in females had no significant short-term effect on energy or macronutr
ient intake. Energy intake was significantly influenced by the fat:car
bohydrate composition of the foods available (F(1,12)=64.7, P<0.001),
and the short-term energy deficit induced by exercise when followed by
low-fat lunch was completely wiped out when exercise was followed by
a high-fat lunch (F(1,12)=66.2, P<0.001). Conclusions: These results s
how that there are similarities and differences between males and fema
les in the appetite response to foods varying in macronutrient composi
tion following vigorous exercise. The differences may help to explain
why exercise so often produces a disappointing effect on weight contro
l in females.