Na. Graham et Jr. Kershner, READING STYLES IN CHILDREN WITH DYSLEXIA - A NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL EVALUATION OF MODALITY PREFERENCE ON THE READING STYLE INVENTORY, Learning disability quarterly, 19(4), 1996, pp. 233-240
This study assessed the neuropsychological validity of the modality pr
eference measures from the Reading Style inventory (RSI), an instrumen
t that claims to measure left-hemisphere (analytic, sequential, audito
ry) and right-hemisphere (holistic, simultaneous, visual) reading styl
es, Older fluent readers (age-matched to the children with disabilitie
s) rated their reading styles more strongly auditory and visual than n
ondisabled beginning readers (reading-level-matched to the children wi
th disabilities) and children with dyslexia, Compared to both control
groups, the dyslexia group was unique in failing to demonstrate a high
incidence of children with strong preferences in either modality, RSI
ratings were unrelated to dichotic listening and, by inference, not r
elated to the relative activation of the cerebral hemispheres in lingu
istic processing, RSI performance was also unrelated to reading compre
hension, word recognition, word attack, and verbal/performance IQ, The
results do not support the underlying biological rationale of the RSI
or its claims to accurately profile nondisabled novice readers and ch
ildren with dyslexia in terms of their cerebral hemispheric preference
s, However, the results do suggest the potential usefulness of the RSI
in educational contexts,