The paper presents and critiques some important philosophical and educ
ational arguments that are used to support the practice of personal se
lf-disclosure in the classroom, both in group settings and in the form
of autobiographical journals. It argues that there are important reas
ons for valuing privacy even when self-disclosures occur in an environ
ment of perfect trust and caring; that to understand the importance of
privacy primarily in terms of trust, or the absence of trust, is to r
isk overlooking the less apparent, yet more subtle, threats which 'sym
pathy' and 'caring' can pose to self-disclosers.