Bh. Cornish et al., EVALUATION OF MULTIPLE FREQUENCY BIOELECTRICAL-IMPEDANCE AND COLE-COLE ANALYSIS FOR THE ASSESSMENT OF BODY-WATER VOLUMES IN HEALTHY HUMANS, European journal of clinical nutrition, 50(3), 1996, pp. 159-164
Objective: To assess the application of a Cole-Cole analysis of multip
le frequency bioelectrical impedance analysis (MFBIA) measurements to
predict total body water (TEW) and extracellular water (ECW) in humans
. This technique has previously been shown to produce accurate and rel
iable estimates in both normal and abnormal animals. Design: The whole
body impedance of 60 healthy humans was measured at 496 frequencies (
ranging from 4 kHz to 1 MHz) and the impedance at zero frequency, R(0)
, and at the characteristic frequency, Z(c), were determined from the
impedance spectrum, (Cole-Cole plot). TEW and ECW were independently d
etermined using deuterium and bromide tracer dilution techniques. Sett
ing: At the Dunn Clinical Nutrition Centre and The Department of Bioch
emistry, University of Queensland. Subjects: 60 healthy adult voluntee
rs (27 men and 33 women, aged 18-45 years).Results: The results presen
ted suggest that the swept frequency bioimpedance technique estimates
total body water, (SEE = 5.2%), and extracellular water, (SEE = 10%),
only slightly better in normal, healthy subjects than a method based o
n single frequency bioimpedance or anthropometric estimates based on w
eight, height and gender. Conclusions: This study has undertaken the m
ost extensive analysis to date of relationships between TEW (and ECW)
and individual impedances obtained at different frequencies ( > 400 fr
equencies), and has shown marginal advantages of using one frequency o
ver another, even if values predicted from theoretical bioimpedance mo
dels are used in the estimations. However in situations where there ar
e disturbances of fluid distribution, values predicted from the Cole-C
ole analysis of swept frequency bioimpedance measurements could prove
to be more useful.