K. Brookewavell et al., EVALUATION OF NEAR-INFRARED INTERACTANCE FOR ASSESSMENT OF SUBCUTANEOUS AND TOTAL-BODY FAT, European journal of clinical nutrition, 49(1), 1995, pp. 57-65
Objective: Near infra-red interactance (NIRI) has been used for assess
ment of total body fatness, but its relationship with composition at t
he measurement site is not clear This study examines the relationship
of interactance with subcutaneous adipose tissue and muscle thickness
as well as total body fat content. Design: (i) Validation of NW by com
parison with subcutaneous tissue thicknesses from ultrasound. (ii) Cro
ss-validation of techniques for estimation of body fat content. Settin
g: Laboratory. Subjects: (i) 54 young adults (27 male and 27 female) a
nd (ii) 63 middle-aged men. Interventions: Measurements of subcutaneou
s adipose tissue thickness and muscle thickness using ultrasound near
infra-red interactance (Futrex 5000) and skinfold thicknesses were mad
e at five sites in young adults. In middle-aged men total body fat was
assessed by densitometry, NIRI and skinfold thickness. Measurements w
ere made in duplicate by a single trained observer. Results: Interacta
nce measurements were related to subcutaneous adipose tissue thickness
, although the relationship varied according to measurement site (r =
0.09 at anterior thigh to 0.78 at biceps; P = 0.31 to <0.0001). Muscle
thickness explained additional variance in interactance only at bicep
s in women. Subcutaneous adipose tissue thickness correlated better wi
th skinfold thickness (r = 0.56 to 0.92; P = 0.002 to <0.0001) than wi
th interactance. Mean difference in fat mass from densitometry +/- 95%
limits of agreement was -1.61 +/- 7.68 kg for NIRI and -2.84 +/- 6.56
kg for skinfold thickness in middle-aged men. NW tended to underestim
ate higher (and overestimate lower) levels of fatness.Conclusions: NIR
I performed no better than skinfolds in assessment of either subcutane
ous or total body fat. Sponsorship: This work was supported by the Bri
tish Heart Foundation.