The image of Asian-Americans as ''model minorities'' is driven, in par
t, by the high academic achievement of Asian-American children. To eva
luate this characterization, I use the National Education Longitudinal
Study of 1988 (NELS:88) to compare Asian and white eighth graders on
reading and math test scores and grades. Results indicate that the dif
ference between Asians overall and whites on reading and math test sco
res can be explained by differences in family background. However, ana
lyses by Asian subgroups reveal that Chinese, Korean and Southeast Asi
an youth earn higher math scores while Pacific Islanders earn consider
ably lower math and reading scores than their white counterparts. Whit
es and Asians differ substantially in their grade performance, which s
uggests that cultural and behavioral differences may be an important i
nfluence on grades. Analyses of Asian subgroups show no statistical pe
rceivably higher grades than whites after controlling for the effects
of family characteristics.