R. Vanderveer, THE CONCEPT OF DEVELOPMENT AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF CONCEPTS - EDUCATION AND DEVELOPMENT IN VYGOTSKYS THINKING, European journal of psychology of education, 9(4), 1994, pp. 293-300
A major theme of Vygotsky's research in the Inner part of his life was
the theme of concept formation or conceptual development in child dev
elopment. He argued that the acquisition of mature scientific (academi
c) concepts forms the crowning achievement of adolescsence. Mature con
ceptual thinking positively influences the cognitive domain but also t
he aesthetic reactions and emotions. Conversely, the breakdown of conc
eptual thinking in pathology will lead to severe intellectual impairme
nt but also to emotional dullness etc. In this paper it is claimed tha
t this view is highly interesting but a number of criticisms are raise
d. Specifically, it is argued that (1) the resulting view is overly ra
tionalistic; (2) the notion of scientific concepts seems to imply a so
mewhat static view of science; and (3) Vygotsky was perhaps too optimi
stic about the possibility of transfer of scientific (conceptual) thin
king to other domains.