Fourteen hearing-impaired children with a mean age of 11.2 years and a
mean hearing loss of 84.42 dB were compared with an age-matched heari
ng control on their performance on the Picture Aided Reading Test (PAR
T) (1971) and a Saliency Test. Beggs and Breslaw (1983) claimed that h
earing-impaired pupils' performance on some items of the PART is the p
roduct of a non-reading strategy involving the selection of the visual
ly most salient pictures. Our replication of their two experiments sug
gests that there is no evidence for their claim.