Ab. Lusk et As. Weinberg, DISCUSSING CONTROVERSIAL TOPICS IN THE CLASSROOM - CREATING A CONTEXTFOR LEARNING, Teaching sociology, 22(4), 1994, pp. 301-308
Efforts to initiate classroom discussions of controversial topics ofte
n provoke either uncomfortable silence or unthoughtful responses from
students. In this research, we focus on one factor that makes discussi
ons of controversial topics difficult: students' assumption that they
will suffer negative repercussions from any discussion of controversia
l topics. We outline an exercise that encourages students to analyze f
rom a sociological perspective the classroom dynamics, including their
own discomfort, which make discussion of these issues difficult. The
exercise addresses the problem by demonstrating to students that their
world will not fall apart if they join class discussion, and that the
ir assumptions are rooted in traditional middle- and upper middle-clas
s expectations and norms. By clarifying the roots of their fears and t
he factors involved in their past experiences, we begin to construct a
lternative expectations and interaction patterns that will guide futur
e group discussion in our class.