Students from two consecutive semesters were given multiple-choice tes
ts over five units of an undergraduate course in psychology. During th
e first semester, students were given five 50-question 4-option multip
le-choice tests, and during the second semester students were given fi
ve 50-question 3-option multiple-choice tests. One-hundred and forty-f
our (57.6%) of the questions were identical between semesters except f
or second semester test items having only 3 options. Results indicate
that students performed significantly better on 3-option items than on
4-option items (corrected for chance guessing), and that this improve
ment may be due to improved validity of the test items.