J. Macias, FORGOTTEN HISTORY - EDUCATIONAL AND SOCIAL ANTECEDENTS OF HIGH ACHIEVEMENT AMONG ASIAN IMMIGRANTS IN THE UNITED-STATES, Curriculum inquiry, 23(4), 1993, pp. 409-432
Recent studies of ethnic minority group education in the United States
include comparative analyses between the growing cohort of Asian-Amer
icans and the ethnic minorities of longer standing. The educational re
cord of Asian-Americans, especially that of recent immigrants, tends t
o be markedly superior to the patterns of poor school adjustment, low
achievement, and high dropout rates among American Indians, blacks, an
d Hispanics. A current view in the literature posits a causal link bet
ween group cultural traits and the apparent paradox of Asian success a
nd ethnic minority failure patterns. But a historical view shows that
many Asian immigrants have received in their home countries a rigorous
education tending to focus on science, technology, and related areas.
In the United States they are a select group whose succeeding generat
ions replicate their parents' upwardly mobile educational and economic
patterns that surpass those of all other ethnic groups, even whites.
Asian immigrant successes are largely a product of institutional and s
ocial treatments but so are other structural effects, including their
relatively few study and occupational choices, an occupational ceiling
, as well as the social problems, poor economic mobility, and problema
tic educational experiences of many from certain Asian ethnic groups.
Historical, structural factors and cultural politics are key to a comp
arative understanding of the diversity and commonality of ethnic group
experiences in the United States.