M. Kilduff et D. Krackhardt, BRINGING THE INDIVIDUAL BACK IN - A STRUCTURAL-ANALYSIS OF THE INTERNAL MARKET FOR REPUTATION IN ORGANIZATIONS, Academy of Management journal, 37(1), 1994, pp. 87-108
We challenge the claimed incommensurability of individualism and struc
turalism by showing how a cognitive theory can guide the use of struct
ural methods. According to balance theory, there is a strain toward co
gnitive balance in observers' perceptions of friendship relations. Thu
s, we found, as predicted, that being perceived to have a prominent fr
iend in an organization boosted an individual's reputation as a good p
erformer, but that actually having such a friend (as assessed by conve
ntional structural methods] had no effect. Bringing individual percept
ions back into structural analysis enhances, rather than detracts from
, the effectiveness of a structural approach.