Pc. Dagnelie et al., EFFECTS OF MACROBIOTIC DIETS ON LINEAR GROWTH IN INFANTS AND CHILDRENUNTIL 10 YEARS OF AGE, European journal of clinical nutrition, 48, 1994, pp. 190000103-190000112
In order to study the relationship between diet and growth, we have as
sessed growth patterns in children 0-10 years old on macrobiotic diets
. A cross-sectional anthropometric study (0-8 years old children, n =
243) indicated that deviation from the reference growth curve occurred
during the weaning period. Between 2 and 4 years there was a partial
catch-up for weight and arm circumference but not for height. As a nex
t step, a mixed-longitudinal study was performed in 4-18-month-old mac
robiotic infants (n = 53) and matched omnivorous controls (n = 57). Fo
r a period of 6 months, data on growth and dietary intake were collect
ed. The data on linear growth supported the findings on growth stagnat
ion observed cross-sectionally. Linear growth was associated with the
protein content of the diet, but not with energy intake. On the basis
of our findings nutritional modifications to the macrobiotic diet (add
ition of fat and fish) were recommended for all macrobiotic families.
Six months later (two years after the first cross-sectional data colle
ction) the anthropometric study was repeated in the same cohort (n = 1
94). This follow-up study revealed that children from families which,
since die initial study, had increased the consumption of fatty fish,
dairy products, or both, had grown in height more rapidly than the rem
aining children (P < 0.05). Since no indications were found for the pr
esence of adverse social circumstances, infectious diseases or other c
onfounding factors, our data clearly demonstrate that linear growth re
tardation in children on macrobiotic diets is caused by nutritional de
ficiencies alone.