En. Emerson et Dm. Stein, ANOREXIA-NERVOSA - EMPIRICAL-BASIS FOR THE RESTRICTING AND BULIMIC SUBTYPES, Journal of nutrition education, 25(6), 1993, pp. 329-336
The future revision of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders (DSM-IV) will describe diagnostic criteria for two anorexia
nervosa subgroups: a binge eating or bulimic subtype, and a severe fo
od restriction subtype. The present literature review will help orient
nutrition nd dietetic students, educators and researchers to the empi
rical lases for these subtypes. Available research on these two subtyp
es is equivocal. However, some important trends have emerged. Compared
with restricting anorexics, bulimic anorexics are described by others
as being significantly more unhappy during childhood and displaying a
greater range of impulsive behaviors. In addition, bulimic anorexics
have a higher lifetime prevalence of formal mood disorders, tend to us
e more alcohol and drugs, and tend to meet the criteria for DSM III-R
Cluster B Personality disorders rather than those for Cluster C. Also,
the bulimic subtype tends to have a more chaotic family environment.
Finally, more patients of the bulimic subtype seem to show subaverage
bone density, suggesting a higher risk for chronic osteoporosis. The p
resent review discusses the significant research and treatment implica
tions of the differences between these anorexic subtypes.