The case studies in this article demonstrate how 4 middle grade teache
rs addressed the challenges and dilemmas of enacting project-based sci
ence in their classrooms. The teachers attempted to enact several comm
on features of project-based science, including student collaboration
and ownership and the use of technology. The 4 teachers faced dilemmas
with respect to balancing their use of time and content coverage with
granting students autonomy. They also needed to solve the problems of
addressing their district's curriculum while engaging their students
in project-based science and of maintaining order as they attempted th
is new approach to teaching science. Project-based science was present
ed as a way to think about innovative instruction by providing a possi
ble means of enactment and not a method. We found that the potential o
f project-based science could be realized through teachers' collaborat
ive work with peers, enacting projects in their classrooms, and reflec
ting on their enactments. We also found that teachers' understanding t
ook the form of practical, not theoretical or propositional, knowledge
.